• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
live love fruit logo

Live Love Fruit

Eat Vibrantly. Live Vibrantly

About Start Here Work With Me

  • Home
  • Start Here
  • About
  • Health
  • Remedies
  • Recipes
  • A-Z Conditions
  • Fitness
  • Environment
  • Self Improvement
  • My LLF
  • Shop
Category: > Health > Milk and Mucus: Why Dairy is The Major Cause of Your Phlegm, Mucus and Congestion Issues
✓ Evidence Based

✓ Evidence Based

The content on LiveLoveFruit is fact checked to ensure our readers are given authentic, evidence-based, factually accurate information.

Our strict editorial guidelines mean we only link to academic research institutions, academic journals, reputable media sites and when research is available, medically peer-reviewed studies. If there is any lack of sufficient evidence, it will be noted. All sources are labeled as numbers in parentheses (1, 2, etc.), which are clickable links to studies referenced.

If you notice any discrepancies in our content, please contact us. Your feedback helps us serve you better and makes your experience with us that much better.

Milk and Mucus: Why Dairy is The Major Cause of Your Phlegm, Mucus and Congestion Issues

Jan 18, 2018 Carly Fraser Save For Later Print

Last Updated: Feb 07, 2020

127.7K shares
  • Facebook127.6K
  • Twitter1
  • LinkedIn
milk in glass bottles next to airway clogged with mucus

It seems to be the case that there is a lot of confusion about whether milk and other dairy products create mucus in the body.

The Dairy Council denies that there is any association between milk and increased mucus production, but personal accounts (including myself) and other scientific studies have proven otherwise.

Bias in Nutrition Studies

First I would like to address the fact that nutrition studies funded by food companies (like dairy councils) are almost always biased in their interest.

A new study, co-authored by Harvard researchers and analysts from the Centre for Science in the Public Interest, found just that. They documented widespread bias in nutrition studies funded with industry money. The study they carried out questioned whether the science behind nutrition recommendations is, in fact, legitimate (1).

Dr. David Ludwig, director of the clinical weight loss program at the Children’s Hospital in Boston, analyzed 206 studies published between 1999 and 2003. He decided to focus mainly on milk and other fruit juices and soft drinks, as those beverages are “highly profitable and heavily advertised to children.”

Dr. Ludwig had a group of investigators analyze nutrition studies’ scientific conclusions without knowing anything about the financial sponsorship they had received. A separate group looked up who funded the studies, without knowing anything about the first group’s conclusions.

What did they find? When a food company pays for a scientific article, the results are eight times more likely to be favorable to the company’s financial interests than if the study were independently funded.

So of course, when we see studies funded by the Dairy Council and other dairy companies, we can be rest assured that the results are going to be in favor of the dairy industry. This is similar to what we see when milk gets promoted as building “better bones,” when in fact it does the exact opposite.

According to Kelly Brownell, director of the Rudd Centre for Food Policy and Obesity at Yale University, “both the dairy and the soft drink industries are notorious for giving investigators money to do studies that typically find things favorable to the industry. And if the studies are biased, which they appear to be, we’re not getting the correct picture (2).”  Brownell goes on to say that while the studies are published and peer-reviewed in scientific journals, it is still no guarantee that the researchers or their conclusions are free of bias.

Whether the questions are framed in ways to make them more favorable or studies with negative conclusions are never published, always consider the source of where the information you’re looking at comes from. Who paid for the study you’re getting the information?

Dairy and Mucus Production

While I am not lactose intolerant, I did suffer from a lot of mucus production before giving up dairy. I receive countless e-mails and comments from people about how their mucus and phlegm issues cleared up as soon as they gave up dairy. And while I do recognize that everyone’s experiences are different, I wanted to take a look into the studies that have found dairy to be a trigger for mucus production.

If you’re not aware, casein is a milk protein and is usually involved in the mucus response. And while I do not, by any means, support the use of animals for study, some of the studies that examine dairy and mucus involve rats. Maybe one day we can get past the use of animals to study on, and instead use easier methods of study, like personal accounts of how individuals feel after eliminating a certain food group (aka. dairy) from their diets – just like I did, and noticed significant changes in how I felt.

Study #1: the milk protein casein breaks down in the stomach to produce a substance called casomorphin, which has opioid effects (this makes sense from an evolutionary standpoint as species survival may depend on a close maternal bond between infant and mother). Opioid receptors on the mucous glands in the respiratory tract may respond to the casomorphin from milk, which stimulates the production and secretion of mucus from these respiratory glands. This explains why a subgroup of the population who have increased respiratory tract mucus production find that many of their symptoms, including asthma, improve on a dairy elimination diet.

Study #2: feeding higher levels of dietary animal protein (like casein used in this study) increases colonic DNA damage and thins the colonic mucus barrier in rats. Thinning of the natural mucus barrier in the colon often leads to issues like irritable bowel syndrome (we all have mucosal cells in our body (it’s a good thing, and protects the organs). It’s when we give the body irritating foods, like dairy, when mucus production goes into overdrive). This leads to modified mucus production in the colon and can result in things like mucus showing up in the stool. I used to suffer from irritable bowel syndrome, and once I gave up dairy, I no longer suffered from the symptoms (including mucus in my stool).

The University of Maryland Medical Centre states on their website that to reduce symptoms of cystic fibrosis, to eliminate potential food allergens and foods that increase mucus production, including dairy (milk, cheese, sour cream, and ice cream), wheat (gluten), soy and corn, and to eat more foods that decrease mucus production like garlic, onions, watercress, horseradish, mustard, parsley, celery, and lemon.

WebMD, a popular medical website also supports the hypothesis that phlegm can be made worse with the ingestion of dairy products like milk, ice cream, and cheese. Dr. Neil L. Kao, MD, associate professor of medicine at the University of South Carolina School of Medicine says on WedMD that the reason people produce more mucus when they drink milk is because of gustatory rhinitis. Gustatory rhinitis is a reflex reaction triggered by eating. It is also why your nose runs when you eat hot peppers – the same thing happens when some people consume dairy products. Hot peppers are an irritant, and so is dairy. Rhinitis means inflammation of the nasal passages, and when the body triggers the inflammatory response, it usually means it is trying to protect itself or repair itself from damage (aka. from the irritant (dairy) you put in your body).

Mayo Clinic also states that drinking milk makes phlegm thicker and more irritating to your throat than it normally would be when you have a sore throat. Unfortunately, the same applies to when your throat isn’t sore – you just don’t notice it as much when your throat isn’t sore and irritated.

Studies Funded By Dairy Industry

To demonstrate just a few studies (amongst many others) that are funded by the dairy industry, I’ll leave a short list below. These studies, of course, only mention positive results. You’ll never find a negative study result being funded by the dairy industry.

Study #1 – Funded by the Swiss Federal Research Station for Animal Production and Dairy Products (ALP).

Study #2 – Funded by the Global Dairy Platform, Dairy Research Institute, and Dairy Australia. An author of the study received the Wiebe Visser International Dairy Nutrition Prize from the Dutch Dairy Association’s (NZO) Utrecht Group. Another author of the study is the recipient of research grants from the Danish Dairy Research Foundation, the Global Dairy Platform, the Danish Agriculture and Food Council and the GEIE European Milk Forum.

Study #3 – Studies lead author, Jonathon Maguire, has a long history of receiving money from the dairy industry and of publishing studies with unsubstantiated conclusions that are favorable to the dairy industry (3). In this study, it is suggested that cow’s milk is essential for obtaining vitamin D, but the problem here is that vitamin D isn’t even found naturally in milk – it’s artificially added by milk processors. The best place to get vitamin D? The sun. This study was a project of TARGet Kids, which lists as funders – Dairy Farmers of Ontario and the Danone Institute.

Study #4 – Fully funded by the dairy industry, including the Dairy Research Institute and the Danish Dairy Research Foundation. The study was criticized in a letter to the editor of the journal, and stated that the “experimental diets were apparently designed so that the possibly desired conclusion could be drawn (4).”

The National Osteoporosis Society also warned that diets, which cut out dairy, could be a “ticking time bomb” for young people’s bone health, a claim made after the Society carried out a survey that found a fifth of under-25s has cut down on or completely given up dairy.

What this scaremongering survey fails to mention is that the National Osteoporosis Society is funded by a dairy company – Yoplait (5) – and that the company “donates annually to the National Osteoporosis Society in the UK and the Irish Osteoporosis in Ireland (6).”

Of course, this is false information that the National Osteoporosis Society is spreading, as children and adults alike can get calcium from plant-food sources like kale, sesame seeds, okra, dried figs, chia seeds, almonds and more. Calcium from plant-based sources is actually better for you than dairy, as the high acidity in dairy actually buffers the pH in the body, stripping alkaline minerals (like calcium) from the bones.

Can You Get Enough Calcium From Plants?

Quick answer: yes!

Many people aren’t aware that certain plant foods are high in calcium. This is because the dairy industry pushes its products so hard through marketing and advertising that they have completely brain-washed society into thinking dairy is the only way we can get calcium.

This is far from the truth!

Plant foods are actually some of the best sources of calcium. There are two reasons for this.

  1. Dairy is high acid, and plant foods are alkaline. The high acidity of dairy actually makes the body pull alkaline minerals from the bones (like calcium and magnesium), making them weaker and more prone to fracture. Plant foods, on the other hand, are mineral-rich and don’t strip alkaline minerals from our bones.

  2. Plant foods are just high in calcium, period! Everything from bok choy to kale and collards. Just two tablespoons of chia seeds contain six times the amount of calcium found in a glass of milk! You can find an entire list of plant-based foods high in calcium here.

So instead of reaching for a container of dairy the next time you’re at the grocery store, why not reach for some coconut milk? I highly suggest making your own oat or almond milk, because it is much easier (and cheaper) than buying your own! Most of the almond milk in stores is watered down with other ingredients too, so by making your own, you’ll make sure you’re only getting the good stuff.

I personally love making my own coconut yogurt. You can find this recipe and more in my Freedom from Inflammation recipe eBook, which is packed with over 50+ plant-based recipes to reduce inflammation in your body to restore your health!

freedom from inflammation recipe ebook

The Bottom Line

While many believe that dairy is not the cause of mucus – studies say otherwise. The studies that claim dairy doesn’t create mucus are directly funded by the dairy industry, so massive bias lies in resultant data.

Regardless of studies and science, when will people start listening to their body and recognizing what certain foods elicit in their body upon consumption? What do you think? Do you notice a difference when you stop consuming dairy?

127.7K shares
  • Facebook127.6K
  • Twitter1
  • LinkedIn

Filed Under: Food Education, Health Tagged With: excess mucus, how dairy causes mucus, milk and mucus, milk causes mucus, mucus production

Carly Fraser

About the Author

Carly Fraser has her BSc (Hons.) Degree in Neuroscience, and is the owner and founder at Live Love Fruit. She currently lives in Winnipeg, Manitoba, with a determined life mission to help inspire and motivate individuals to critically think about what they put in their bodies and to find balance through nutrition and lifestyle. She has helped hundreds of thousands of individuals to re-connect with their bodies and learn self-love through proper eating habits and natural living. She loves to do yoga, dance, and immerse herself in nature.

View Profile

Reader Interactions

Related Posts

  • 10 Great Reasons Why You Should Ditch Milk and Dairy Products
  • Get Rid of Mucus Congestion and Sinus Problems with this Mucus-Clearing Juice Recipe
  • Remove Mucus From Your Body With These 3 Simple Ingredients
  • mucus cleansing herbs
    20 Mucus Cleansing Herbs, Fruit and Vegetables to Alleviate Excessive Mucus in the Body
  • 20 Plant Foods That Contain More Calcium Than Milk and Other Dairy Products
  • A Simple Fennel Juice To Treat Anemia and Indigestion and Clear Mucus
  • 12 Foods That Cause Excessive Mucus In The Body (and 14 Foods That Eliminate It!)

Comments

  1. Daniele Azevedo-Silva says

    Jan 12, 2021 at 9:06 am

    I’m assuming that drinking lactose free milk will not make a difference since the casein protein still present. Right?

    Reply
    • Carly Fraser says

      Jan 15, 2021 at 11:43 am

      Correct.

      Reply
  2. Gregory Mahaits says

    Mar 4, 2021 at 5:13 pm

    Is butter safe to use ? I am just now stopping my use of milk and cheese and cream. But i do like to use butter.

    Reply
    • Carly Fraser says

      Mar 11, 2021 at 5:56 pm

      Butter is still technically a dairy product, so I would avoid it.

      Reply
  3. Annette M Schexnayder says

    Mar 20, 2021 at 9:16 am

    I have been having excessive mucus in my throat for 6 months now. It’s a little better as I am not spitting up mucus all day long but do still spit when I eat or drink anything. I got off all dairy for months and it made no difference so I went back to regular Latose Fat Free milk. I could not stand millk. I am feeling better and have gained a few pounds. I had lot 15 pounds and I looked and felt bad.

    Reply
  4. Marvyn says

    Apr 20, 2021 at 10:57 am

    I’ve tried nut milks and oat milk and don’t like the taste at all. Is goat milk or camel milk an option?

    Reply
    • Carly Fraser says

      May 6, 2021 at 5:15 pm

      Goat milk and camel milk will have the same effects. You may just need to try different brands of plant-based milks or make your own (making your own usually results in better tasting milks).

      Reply
« Older Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Free Ebook

Success! Please check your inbox to download your FREE eBook.

Reduce Chronic Inflammation Naturally!

The Ultimate Guide to Fight Inflammation and Restore Your Health!

21 Ways to Reduce Chronic Inflammation

Recent Posts

visual illustration of toxins stored in fat cells in body

How to Eliminate Toxins From Fat Cells That Are Making You Fatigued and Swollen

foot with demonstrated achilles pain

This One Stretch Relieves Plantar Fasciitis, Shin Splints, Achilles Pain, and Heel Pain

Neutrogena and Aveeno sunscreens recalled by Johnson & Johnson

Latest Sunscreen Recall Raises Concern Over Chemicals

lemongrass plant in garden

How to Plant Lemongrass to Repel Mosquitoes

Female Reproductive System next to adrenal glands representing organs in the body responsible for hormone production

10 Natural Ways to Balance Your Hormones

freshly pressed pineapple juice

15 Impressive Health Benefits of Pineapple Juice

Popular Posts

Man spraying pesticides on tea plants with other side of image showing dry loose tea bags

Pesticides in Tea: Is Your Favorite Tea Contaminated with Harmful Chemicals?

glyphosate in wine

Monsanto’s Harmful Chemical Glyphosate Found In 100% Of California Wines Tested

whole dandelion plant with flowers and roots on cutting board on a table

Dandelions Are Not Weeds! Top 10 Health Benefits of Dandelion

johnson & johnson baby products in pharmacy

Johnson & Johnson Finally Admits: Our Baby Products Contain Cancer-Causing Ingredients

10 Plants That Attract Dragonflies for Mosquito Control

companion planting chart

Use This Companion Planting Chart to Help Your Garden Thrive

France Bans Neonicotinoid Pesticides

France Bans All Five Neonicotinoid Pesticides Linked to Bee Deaths

Glyphosate in Food: Complete List of Products and Brands Filled with Dangerous Weed-Killer

whales dying from plastic pollution

Whales Dying From Plastic Pollution Are a Grave Reminder to Give Up Our Addiction to Plastics

illustrated piriformis muscle showing trigger points and radiating pain

How To Get A Deep Piriformis Stretch To Get Rid of Sciatica, Hip & Lower Back Pain

RECOMMENDED

Thank you! Please check your inbox to confirm your subscription!

Want to reduce inflammation and restore your health?

Join Live Love Fruit and we'll show you how!

Footer

Stay Connected!

Follows
  • 317k Followers
  • 1.9k Followers
  • 107k Followers
  • 600 Followers
  • 11.5k Followers
  • Home
  • About
  • Start Here
  • Write For LLF
  • Contact

Any medical information published on this website is not intended as a substitute for informed medical advice and you should not take any action before consulting with a healthcare professional.
Content on Live Love Fruit may not be reproduced in any form.
Ads provided by AdThrive. Displayed ads do not constitute endorsement or recommendation by Live Love Fruit.

Copyright © 2012 - 2022 Live Love FruitPrivacy Policy | Terms of Service | Full Disclaimer | Affiliate Disclosure

127.7K shares
  • 127.6K
  • 1